دولة فاشلة

الدول الفاشلة وفقا ل"مؤشر الدول الفاشلة عام 2015" لفورين بوليسي .[1]
  مستدامة
  مستقرة
  وضع حذر
  حرجة
  لا معلومات\متنازعة

دولة فاشلة هي دولة ذات حكومة مركزية ضعيفة أو غير فعالة حتى أنها لا تملك إلا القليل من السيطرة على جزء كبير من أراضيها. مستوى الرقابة اللازمة لتفادي التي يجري النظر فيها لدولة على أنها دولة فاشلة مختلف عليه. وعلاوة على ذلك، فإن إعلان أن دولة ما قد «فشلت» هو موضوع جدل عموماً، وعندما يتم رسمياً، قد يحمل عواقب سياسية كبيرة.[2]

مفهوم المصطلح[عدل]

تصبح الدولة فاشلة إذا ظهر عليها عددٌ من الأعراض أولها أن تفقد السلطة القائمة قدرتها على السيطرة الفعلية على أراضيها أو أن تفقد احتكارها لحق استخدام العنف المشروع في الأراضي التي تحكمها. وثانيها هو فقدانها لشرعية اتخاذ القرارات العامة وتنفيذها. وثالثها عجزها عن توفير الحد المعقول من الخدمات العامة. ورابعها عجزها عن التفاعل مع الدول الأخرى كعضو فاعل في الأسرة الدولية.[3]

تندرج الخدمات البلدية والصحية والتعليمية ضمن قائمة الخدمات الأساسية والتوزيعية. كما تندرج مستلزمات إقامة وإدامة أسس التوافق على شرعية الدولة كراعية لمصالح جميع سكان البلاد وليس مصالح فئة أو فئات معدودة منهم. وبالمقابل لم تعد مسؤولية الدولة ولا شرعيتها محصورة خارجياً في الحصول على اعتراف الأسرة الدولية الشكلي بها. تتزايد مستلزمات ذلك الاعتراف الدولي كما تتزايد الالتزامات التي يتطلبها استمرار ذلك الاعتراف في العقديْن الماضييْن.

مؤشر الدول الفاشلة للسنوات السابقة[عدل]

2015[عدل]

البلد 2015 score التغير من 2014[4] التغير من 2013[5] التغير من 2012[6] التغير من 2011[7] التغير من 2010[8] التغير من 2009[9] التغير من 2008[10]
 جنوب السودان 114.5 negative increase 1.6 negative increase 3.9 negative increase 6.1 N/A N/A N/A N/A
 الصومال 114.0 negative increase 1.4 negative increase 0.1 positive decrease 0.9 negative increase 0.6 positive decrease 0.3 positive decrease 0.7 positive decrease 0.2
 جمهورية أفريقيا الوسطى 111.9 negative increase 1.3 negative increase 6.6 negative increase 8.1 negative increase 6.9 negative increase 5.5 negative increase 6.5 negative increase 8.2
 السودان 110.8 negative increase 0.7 positive decrease 0.2 negative increase 1.4 negative increase 2.1 positive decrease 1.0 positive decrease 1.6 positive decrease 2.2
 جمهورية الكونغو الديمقراطية 109.7 positive decrease 0.5 positive decrease 2.2 positive decrease 1.5 negative increase 1.5 positive decrease 0.5 negative increase 1.0 negative increase 3.0
 تشاد 108.4 positive decrease 0.3 positive decrease 0.6 negative increase 0.8 positive decrease 1.9 positive decrease 4.9 positive decrease 3.8 positive decrease 2.5
 اليمن 108.1 negative increase 2.7 negative increase 1.1 negative increase 3.3 negative increase 7.8 negative increase 7.4 negative increase 10.0 negative increase 12.7
 سوريا 107.9 negative increase 6.3 negative increase 10.5 negative increase 13.4 negative increase 22.0 negative increase 20.0 negative increase 18.1 negative increase 17.8
 أفغانستان 107.9 negative increase 1.4 negative increase 1.2 negative increase 1.9 negative increase 0.4 negative increase 0.6 positive decrease 0.3 negative increase 2.5
 غينيا 104.9 negative increase 2.2 negative increase 3.6 negative increase 3.0 negative increase 2.4 negative increase 3.3 negative increase 0.3 negative increase 3.1
 هايتي 104.5 negative increase 0.2 positive decrease 1.3 positive decrease 0.4 positive decrease 3.5 positive decrease 5.4 negative increase 2.7 negative increase 5.2
 العراق 104.5 negative increase 2.3 negative increase 0.6 negative increase 0.2 positive decrease 0.3 positive decrease 0.5 positive decrease 4.1 positive decrease 6.1
 باكستان 102.9 positive decrease 0.1 0.0 negative increase 1.3 negative increase 0.6 negative increase 1.7 positive decrease 1.2 positive decrease 0.9
 نيجيريا 102.4 negative increase 2.7 negative increase 1.7 negative increase 1.3 negative increase 2.5 negative increase 2.2 negative increase 2.6 negative increase 6.7
 ساحل العاج 100.0 positive decrease 1.7 positive decrease 3.5 positive decrease 3.6 positive decrease 2.8 positive decrease 2.5 positive decrease 2.5 positive decrease 4.6
 زيمبابوي 100.0 positive decrease 2.8 positive decrease 5.2 positive decrease 6.3 positive decrease 7.9 positive decrease 9.3 positive decrease 14.0 positive decrease 12.5
 غينيا بيساو 99.9 positive decrease 0.7 positive decrease 1.2 negative increase 0.7 negative increase 1.6 negative increase 2.1 negative increase 5.1 negative increase 8.6
 بوروندي 98.1 negative increase 1.0 negative increase 0.5 negative increase 0.6 positive decrease 0.5 positive decrease 0.7 negative increase 2.4 negative increase 4.0
 النيجر 97.8 positive decrease 0.1 positive decrease 1.2 negative increase 0.9 positive decrease 1.3 positive decrease 2.2 negative increase 1.3 negative increase 3.3
 إثيوبيا 97.5 positive decrease 0.4 positive decrease 1.4 positive decrease 0.4 positive decrease 0.7 positive decrease 0.3 positive decrease 1.4 negative increase 1.4
 كينيا 97.4 positive decrease 1.6 positive decrease 2.2 positive decrease 1.0 positive decrease 1.3 positive decrease 2.0 positive decrease 4.0 negative increase 4.0
 ليبيريا 97.3 negative increase 3.0 negative increase 2.2 negative increase 4.0 negative increase 3.3 negative increase 1.9 negative increase 5.5 negative increase 6.3
 أوغندا 97.0 negative increase 1.0 negative increase 0.4 negative increase 0.5 negative increase 0.7 positive decrease 0.5 negative increase 0.1 negative increase 0.9
 إريتريا 96.9 negative increase 1.4 negative increase 1.9 negative increase 2.4 negative increase 3.3 negative increase 3.3 negative increase 6.6 negative increase 9.5
 ليبيا 95.3 negative increase 7.5 negative increase 10.8 negative increase 10.4 negative increase 26.6 negative increase 26.2 negative increase 25.9 negative increase 25.3
 موريتانيا 94.9 negative increase 1.9 negative increase 3.2 negative increase 7.3 negative increase 6.9 negative increase 6.2 negative increase 6.2 negative increase 8.8
 ميانمار 94.7 negative increase 0.4 negative increase 0.1 positive decrease 1.5 positive decrease 3.6 positive decrease 3.5 positive decrease 6.8 positive decrease 5.6
 الكاميرون 94.3 negative increase 1.2 negative increase 0.8 negative increase 1.2 positive decrease 0.3 positive decrease 1.8 positive decrease 1.0 negative increase 3.1
 كوريا الشمالية 93.8 positive decrease 0.2 positive decrease 1.3 positive decrease 1.7 positive decrease 1.8 positive decrease 3.4 positive decrease 4.5 positive decrease 3.9
 مالي 93.1 negative increase 3.3 negative increase 3.8 negative increase 15.2 negative increase 13.8 negative increase 13.7 negative increase 14.4 negative increase 17.5
 سيراليون 91.9 negative increase 2.0 negative increase 0.7 negative increase 1.5 positive decrease 0.2 positive decrease 1.4 positive decrease 0.2 positive decrease 0.4
 بنغلاديش 91.8 positive decrease 1.0 positive decrease 0.7 positive decrease 0.4 positive decrease 2.6 positive decrease 3.9 positive decrease 6.3 positive decrease 8.5
 جمهورية الكونغو 90.8 negative increase 1.2 negative increase 0.8 negative increase 0.7 positive decrease 0.6 positive decrease 1.4 positive decrease 2.3 positive decrease 2.6
 سريلانكا 90.6 positive decrease 2.0 positive decrease 2.3 positive decrease 1.6 positive decrease 2.5 positive decrease 3.0 positive decrease 6.1 positive decrease 5.0
 تيمور الشرقية 90.6 positive decrease 0.4 positive decrease 0.9 positive decrease 2.1 positive decrease 4.3 positive decrease 6.1 positive decrease 6.6 positive decrease 3.2
 نيبال 90.5 positive decrease 0.5 positive decrease 1.3 positive decrease 2.5 positive decrease 3.2 positive decrease 4.9 positive decrease 4.9 positive decrease 3.7
 رواندا 90.2 positive decrease 0.3 negative increase 0.9 negative increase 0.9 positive decrease 0.8 positive decrease 0.7 negative increase 1.2 negative increase 2.2
 مصر 90.0 positive decrease 1.0 positive decrease 0.6 positive decrease 0.4 negative increase 3.2 negative increase 1.6 negative increase 1.0 negative increase 1.3
 بوركينا فاسو 89.2 negative increase 0.2 positive decrease 1.0 negative increase 1.8 negative increase 0.6 positive decrease 1.2 positive decrease 2.1 positive decrease 0.7
 جيبوتي 88.1 negative increase 1.0 negative increase 2.6 negative increase 4.3 negative increase 5.5 negative increase 4.6 negative increase 7.5 negative increase 8.1
 أنغولا 88.1 negative increase 0.7 negative increase 1.0 negative increase 3.0 negative increase 3.5 negative increase 3.0 negative increase 3.1 negative increase 4.3
 لبنان 88.1 negative increase 1.2 negative increase 1.8 negative increase 2.3 negative increase 0.4 positive decrease 0.5 positive decrease 5.4 positive decrease 7.6
 كمبوديا 87.9 positive decrease 0.6 positive decrease 0.1 positive decrease 0.8 positive decrease 0.6 positive decrease 1.3 negative increase 0.6 negative increase 2.1
 إيران 87.2 0.0 positive decrease 2.5 positive decrease 2.4 positive decrease 3.0 positive decrease 3.5 positive decrease 2.8 negative increase 1.5
 موزمبيق 86.9 negative increase 1.0 negative increase 4.1 negative increase 4.5 negative increase 3.3 negative increase 3.0 negative increase 6.2 negative increase 10.1
 مالاوي 86.9 positive decrease 2.2 positive decrease 2.3 positive decrease 1.9 positive decrease 4.3 positive decrease 4.8 positive decrease 6.9 positive decrease 6.0
 توغو 86.8 positive decrease 1.0 positive decrease 1.0 positive decrease 0.7 positive decrease 2.6 positive decrease 3.7 positive decrease 0.4 0.0
 الفلبين 86.3 negative increase 1.0 negative increase 3.5 negative increase 3.1 negative increase 1.3 positive decrease 0.8 negative increase 0.5 negative increase 2.9
 إسواتيني 86.3 negative increase 0.5 negative increase 0.7 negative increase 2.8 negative increase 3.8 negative increase 3.2 negative increase 3.9 negative increase 6.3
 جزر سليمان 85.9 positive decrease 0.5 negative increase 0.7 negative increase 0.3 0.0 positive decrease 1.7 positive decrease 3.7 positive decrease 6.5
 غامبيا 85.4 negative increase 2.3 negative increase 3.6 negative increase 4.8 negative increase 4.5 negative increase 3.7 negative increase 6.4 negative increase 8.5
 أوزبكستان 85.4 positive decrease 0.9 positive decrease 1.5 positive decrease 2.1 positive decrease 2.9 positive decrease 3.3 positive decrease 7.4 positive decrease 8.0
 زامبيا 85.2 positive decrease 1.0 positive decrease 1.4 positive decrease 0.7 negative increase 1.4 negative increase 0.8 negative increase 1.0 negative increase 3.6
 غينيا الاستوائية 84.8 positive decrease 0.5 positive decrease 1.3 positive decrease 1.5 positive decrease 3.3 positive decrease 3.9 positive decrease 3.5 positive decrease 3.2
 لاوس 84.5 negative increase 0.2 negative increase 0.8 positive decrease 1.0 positive decrease 2.2 positive decrease 3.7 positive decrease 4.5 positive decrease 4.2
 مدغشقر 83.6 negative increase 0.5 negative increase 0.9 negative increase 1.1 negative increase 0.4 positive decrease 0.2 negative increase 2.0 negative increase 6.9
 طاجيكستان 83.4 positive decrease 1.2 positive decrease 1.8 positive decrease 2.3 positive decrease 4.9 positive decrease 5.7 positive decrease 6.9 positive decrease 5.5
 بابوا غينيا الجديدة 83.4 positive decrease 0.7 positive decrease 1.5 positive decrease 0.3 positive decrease 0.8 positive decrease 1.2 positive decrease 0.7 positive decrease 1.2
 جزر القمر 83.3 positive decrease 1.8 positive decrease 0.7 negative increase 0.3 positive decrease 0.5 positive decrease 0.6 positive decrease 3.0 negative increase 3.7
 السنغال 83.0 negative increase 0.2 negative increase 1.6 negative increase 3.7 negative increase 6.2 negative increase 4.9 negative increase 8.8 negative increase 12.1
 كولومبيا 82.5 positive decrease 0.6 positive decrease 1.3 positive decrease 1.9 positive decrease 4.5 positive decrease 6.0 positive decrease 6.7 positive decrease 6.5
 قرغيزستان 82.2 positive decrease 1.7 positive decrease 3.5 positive decrease 5.2 positive decrease 9.6 positive decrease 10.3 positive decrease 6.9 positive decrease 6.6
 تنزانيا 80.8 0.0 positive decrease 0.3 negative increase 0.4 positive decrease 0.5 positive decrease 1.7 positive decrease 0.3 negative increase 1.7
 غواتيمالا 80.4 negative increase 0.1 positive decrease 0.3 negative increase 1.0 negative increase 0.3 positive decrease 0.8 positive decrease 0.2 positive decrease 0.2
 روسيا 80.0 negative increase 3.5 negative increase 2.9 negative increase 2.9 negative increase 2.3 negative increase 1.3 positive decrease 0.8 negative increase 0.3
 ليسوتو 79.9 negative increase 1.3 negative increase 0.5 negative increase 0.9 positive decrease 0.5 positive decrease 1.4 positive decrease 1.9 positive decrease 1.8
 الجزائر 79.6 negative increase 0.8 negative increase 0.9 negative increase 1.5 negative increase 1.6 negative increase 0.8 positive decrease 1.0 negative increase 1.8
 الهند 79.4 negative increase 2.5 negative increase 1.9 negative increase 1.4 negative increase 0.1 positive decrease 0.6 negative increase 1.6 negative increase 6.5
 إسرائيل/ الضفة الغربية 79.4 positive decrease 0.1 positive decrease 1.4 positive decrease 2.8 positive decrease 5.0 positive decrease 5.5 positive decrease 5.2 positive decrease 4.2
 جورجيا 79.3 positive decrease 3.4 positive decrease 4.9 positive decrease 5.5 positive decrease 7.1 positive decrease 8.8 positive decrease 12.5 positive decrease 4.5
 تايلاند 79.1 negative increase 2.1 negative increase 4.0 negative increase 2.1 negative increase 0.8 positive decrease 0.1 positive decrease 0.1 negative increase 3.5
 نيكاراجوا 79.0 negative increase 0.6 positive decrease 0.2 positive decrease 0.6 positive decrease 2.2 positive decrease 3.2 positive decrease 3.6 positive decrease 2.7
 بنين 78.8 negative increase 0.6 negative increase 0.9 negative increase 0.2 positive decrease 1.2 positive decrease 1.7 negative increase 3.3 negative increase 6.0
 بوتان 78.7 positive decrease 2.2 positive decrease 3.1 positive decrease 3.7 positive decrease 6.3 positive decrease 8.6 positive decrease 8.6 positive decrease 6.7
 فنزويلا 78.6 negative increase 1.9 negative increase 3.3 negative increase 1.3 negative increase 0.4 positive decrease 0.4 positive decrease 0.9 negative increase 0.7
 هندوراس 78.2 negative increase 0.3 positive decrease 0.1 positive decrease 0.3 positive decrease 0.1 positive decrease 1.1 negative increase 1.0 negative increase 3.3
 بوليفيا 78.0 positive decrease 0.9 positive decrease 2.8 positive decrease 4.1 positive decrease 4.9 positive decrease 5.7 positive decrease 8.3 positive decrease 6.2
 تركمانستان 77.5 positive decrease 0.7 negative increase 0.8 negative increase 0.1 positive decrease 2.2 positive decrease 2.7 positive decrease 6.8 positive decrease 8.7
 البوسنة والهرسك 77.4 negative increase 1.5 negative increase 0.9 positive decrease 0.5 positive decrease 3.5 positive decrease 4.3 positive decrease 5.9 positive decrease 6.9
 أذربيجان 77.3 positive decrease 0.5 positive decrease 0.9 positive decrease 2.5 positive decrease 4.6 positive decrease 5.5 positive decrease 7.3 positive decrease 3.7
 الأردن 76.9 negative increase 0.2 negative increase 1.2 negative increase 2.1 negative increase 2.4 negative increase 0.3 positive decrease 1.0 positive decrease 0.4
 فيجي 76.8 positive decrease 2.2 positive decrease 4.0 positive decrease 3.7 positive decrease 4.3 positive decrease 5.1 positive decrease 2.0 negative increase 0.2
 الصين 76.4 positive decrease 2.6 positive decrease 4.5 positive decrease 1.9 positive decrease 3.7 positive decrease 4.8 positive decrease 8.2 positive decrease 3.9
 أوكرانيا 76.3 negative increase 9.1 negative increase 10.4 negative increase 9.1 negative increase 7.3 negative increase 7.1 negative increase 6.6 negative increase 5.5
 الإكوادور 75.9 positive decrease 1.4 positive decrease 2.7 positive decrease 4.2 positive decrease 6.3 positive decrease 7.1 positive decrease 5.3 positive decrease 4.4
 تونس 75.8 positive decrease 1.7 positive decrease 0.7 negative increase 1.6 negative increase 5.7 negative increase 5.2 negative increase 8.2 negative increase 10.2
 بيلاروسيا 75.6 negative increase 0.6 positive decrease 1.1 positive decrease 1.0 positive decrease 2.0 positive decrease 3.1 positive decrease 6.7 positive decrease 8.8
 إندونيسيا 75.0 positive decrease 1.8 positive decrease 3.2 positive decrease 5.6 positive decrease 6.6 positive decrease 7.6 positive decrease 9.1 positive decrease 8.3
 المغرب 74.6 negative increase 0.2 negative increase 0.3 positive decrease 1.5 positive decrease 1.7 positive decrease 2.9 positive decrease 2.5 positive decrease 1.2
 تركيا 74.5 negative increase 0.4 positive decrease 1.4 positive decrease 2.1 negative increase 3.0 negative increase 1.8 positive decrease 3.7 positive decrease 0.9
 جزر المالديف 74.2 positive decrease 1.2 positive decrease 1.2 positive decrease 0.9 positive decrease 1.4 positive decrease 2.8 positive decrease 4.6 positive decrease 6.2
 صربيا 73.8 negative increase 1.8 positive decrease 0.6 positive decrease 1.2 positive decrease 0.6 positive decrease 2.0 positive decrease 5.4 positive decrease 6.3
 ساو تومي وبرينسيب 73.7 positive decrease 2.1 positive decrease 0.9 positive decrease 0.2 positive decrease 0.8 positive decrease 2.4 positive decrease 3.0 positive decrease 4.6
 ميكرونيسيا 73.6 positive decrease 1.0 negative increase 0.7 negative increase 1.7 negative increase 1.7 negative increase 0.6 negative increase 1.7 positive decrease 0.4
 الرأس الأخضر 73.5 positive decrease 0.6 positive decrease 0.2 positive decrease 1.2 positive decrease 2.3 positive decrease 3.5 positive decrease 5.0 positive decrease 7.2
 مولدوفا 73.0 positive decrease 2.1 positive decrease 3.5 positive decrease 5.7 positive decrease 8.2 positive decrease 9.5 positive decrease 12.1 positive decrease 12.7
 فيتنام 72.4 positive decrease 0.3 positive decrease 0.7 positive decrease 1.6 positive decrease 3.7 positive decrease 4.8 positive decrease 4.5 positive decrease 2.2
 بيرو 71.9 positive decrease 1.0 positive decrease 0.4 positive decrease 1.6 positive decrease 1.7 positive decrease 3.4 positive decrease 5.2 positive decrease 5.6
 غانا 71.9 negative increase 1.2 negative increase 2.8 negative increase 4.4 negative increase 4.2 negative increase 4.0 negative increase 5.7 negative increase 7.3
 المكسيك 71.8 negative increase 0.7 positive decrease 1.3 positive decrease 1.8 positive decrease 3.3 positive decrease 5.0 positive decrease 3.6 positive decrease 0.4
 السعودية 71.6 positive decrease 1.5 positive decrease 1.1 positive decrease 1.8 positive decrease 3.6 positive decrease 5.2 positive decrease 5.9 positive decrease 5.3
 السلفادور 71.4 positive decrease 0.6 positive decrease 1.8 positive decrease 3.0 positive decrease 4.6 positive decrease 5.7 positive decrease 5.8 positive decrease 4.1
 باراغواي 71.3 positive decrease 0.3 positive decrease 0.5 negative increase 0.4 positive decrease 1.1 positive decrease 3.2 positive decrease 0.7 positive decrease 1.0
 الغابون 71.3 positive decrease 0.9 positive decrease 1.6 positive decrease 3.3 positive decrease 4.0 positive decrease 5.6 positive decrease 3.1 positive decrease 3.7
 دومينيكا 71.2 positive decrease 2.2 positive decrease 2.0 positive decrease 2.9 positive decrease 5.7 positive decrease 7.1 positive decrease 6.5 positive decrease 7.2
 ناميبيا 70.8 positive decrease 0.7 negative increase 0.4 positive decrease 0.2 positive decrease 0.9 positive decrease 1.9 positive decrease 4.8 positive decrease 2.1
 غويانا 70.5 positive decrease 0.5 positive decrease 0.3 positive decrease 0.9 positive decrease 2.1 positive decrease 4.1 positive decrease 2.5 positive decrease 1.7
 أرمينيا 69.7 positive decrease 1.6 positive decrease 1.6 positive decrease 2.5 positive decrease 2.6 positive decrease 4.4 positive decrease 4.6 positive decrease 1.0
 سورينام 68.4 positive decrease 2.2 positive decrease 2.8 positive decrease 2.8 positive decrease 2.7 positive decrease 4.1 positive decrease 4.8 positive decrease 4.0
 كازاخستان 68.3 positive decrease 0.2 positive decrease 1.5 positive decrease 2.6 positive decrease 1.9 positive decrease 2.8 positive decrease 4.2 positive decrease 4.1
 ساموا 68.2 positive decrease 1.1 positive decrease 0.5 positive decrease 0.3 positive decrease 1.3 positive decrease 1.3 positive decrease 3.2 positive decrease 4.2
 كوبا 67.4 positive decrease 3.4 positive decrease 5.4 positive decrease 5.7 positive decrease 9.2 positive decrease 10.4 positive decrease 13.2 positive decrease 11.2
 جنوب أفريقيا 67.0 negative increase 0.4 positive decrease 0.6 negative increase 0.2 positive decrease 0.6 positive decrease 0.6 positive decrease 0.4 negative increase 4.3
 قبرص 66.2 positive decrease 1.7 positive decrease 0.8 positive decrease 0.6 positive decrease 1.4 positive decrease 1.7 positive decrease 2.7 positive decrease 3.5
 ماليزيا 65.9 positive decrease 0.3 positive decrease 0.2 positive decrease 2.6 positive decrease 2.8 positive decrease 2.8 positive decrease 3.0 positive decrease 1.3
 بليز 65.3 positive decrease 1.7 positive decrease 1.9 positive decrease 1.9 positive decrease 2.4 positive decrease 2.7 positive decrease 4.2 positive decrease 4.9
 جامايكا 64.6 positive decrease 0.3 positive decrease 1.0 positive decrease 1.2 positive decrease 2.5 positive decrease 2.9 positive decrease 4.0 positive decrease 1.1
 مقدونيا 64.5 positive decrease 1.9 positive decrease 3.5 positive decrease 4.6 positive decrease 6.5 positive decrease 7.6 positive decrease 9.9 positive decrease 10.1
 البحرين 64.3 positive decrease 0.4