Abortion in Queensland

From Wikipedia the free encyclopedia

Abortion in Queensland, Australia, is available on request in the first 22 weeks of pregnancy, with the approval of two doctors usually required for later terminations of pregnancy.[1] Queensland law prohibits protesters from coming within 150 metres of an abortion clinic and requires conscientiously objecting doctors to refer women seeking an abortion to a doctor who will provide one. The current legal framework was introduced by the Palaszczuk Labor Government with the passage of the Termination of Pregnancy Act by the Parliament of Queensland on 17 October 2018 in a conscience vote.[2] Before the Termination of Pregnancy Act took effect on 3 December 2018, abortion was subject to the Criminal Code and the common law McGuire ruling, which made abortion unlawful unless the abortion provider had a reasonable belief that a woman's physical or mental health was at risk.[3][4] Availability varies across the state, and is more limited in rural and remote areas outside South East Queensland.[5][6] In the absence of standardised data collection, it is estimated that between 10,000 and 14,000 abortions occur every year in Queensland.[7][8]

History[edit]

Criminalisation[edit]

Queensland abortion law was originally based on section 58 of the British Offences Against the Person Act 1861, which made abortion a crime.[9] The Queensland Criminal Code contained three provisions criminalising abortion:

  • Section 224 made it a criminal offence to administer "any poison or noxious thing" or use "any other means what ever" to procure the miscarriage of a woman, with a maximum penalty of 14 years imprisonment.[10]
  • Section 225 made it illegal for a woman to attempt to procure her own miscarriage, with a maximum penalty of seven years imprisonment.[10]
  • Section 226 made it illegal to assist someone in procuring an abortion, imposing a maximum penalty of three years imprisonment.[10]

Section 282 provided an exemption from criminal liability for anyone performing "a surgical operation upon any person for the patient's benefit, or upon an unborn child for the preservation of the mother’s life".[10]

Official opposition to abortion was particularly strong during the rule of Joh Bjelke-Petersen in the 1970s and 1980s.[11] In 1980 the Bjelke-Petersen Government attempted to criminalise abortion in all circumstances unless a woman's death was imminent. The proposed law, the Pregnancy Termination Control Bill, passed its first reading but was voted down in the second reading when 19 government members crossed the floor to vote against it.[11]

During these years, many Queensland Women seeking abortion were forced to travel to Sydney, aided by Children By Choice[12] and by Control Abortion Referral Service.

In 1985 Queensland Police launched "Operation Lost Cause" and raided two abortion clinics, seizing thousands of patient files and prosecuting one abortion provider for breaching the Criminal Code.[11][13] The abortion provider was found not guilty, with his case leading to the McGuire ruling that clarified the circumstances when abortion was lawful.[11]

1986 McGuire ruling[edit]

Before the passage of the Abortion Law Reform Act 2008 in Victoria, that state's legal approach to abortion was similar to that prevailing in New South Wales and Queensland.[9] In the 1969 Victorian case of R v Davidson, Justice Clifford Menhennitt of the Supreme Court of Victoria ruled that an abortion performed in the reasonable belief it was necessary to protect the woman's physical or mental wellbeing was lawful, which became known as the "Menhennitt ruling".[14]

The Menhennitt ruling was applied in the 1986 Queensland case R v Bayliss; R v Cullen by Judge McGuire of the District Court of Queensland, which he considered to mirror the lawful abortion exemption established by section 282 of the Criminal Code.[15] This resulting "McGuire ruling" allowed abortion to protect a woman's physical or mental health, and was upheld on appeal by the Supreme Court of Queensland.[10] In 1995 the McGuire ruling was followed by then-Justice Paul de Jersey in the Supreme Court case of Veivers v Connolly.[16][17]

2009 prosecution and changes[edit]

In 2009 a Cairns couple was charged by Queensland Police under anti-abortion laws after imported mifepristone was found in their home. This led to Queensland hospitals refusing to perform medical abortions given the section 282 exemption from criminal liability appeared to cover only surgical abortion.[18] The couple was found not guilty.[19][20]

The case led the Bligh Government to amend section 232 of the Criminal Code to expand its legal immunity for exempt surgical abortions to also include medical abortions. Despite her personal support for decriminalisation, Anna Bligh refused to introduce broader changes to abortion laws, stating that a conscience vote on decriminalisation would fail and might actually lead to tighter restrictions.[19][21][22] Bligh's approach was criticised by doctors but welcomed by the Australian Christian Lobby's Jim Wallace.[18][23]

On 3 September 2009 the Criminal Code (Medical Amendment)[24] was passed by the Parliament of Queensland after a one-hour debate, with independent politician Liz Cunningham the only vote against. Aside from expanding the scope of the section 282 exemption from criminal liability, the amendments also allow women to self-administer abortifacients in accordance with a prescription.[22]

2016 child abortion case and Pyne bills[edit]

In the 2016 Queensland Supreme Court case of Central Queensland Hospital and Health Service v Q,[25] Justice Duncan McMeekin authorised a 12-year-old girl to undergo an abortion due to the risk of self-harm and suicide.[26][27] The case led abortion advocates to criticise the need for court involvement in such cases, with Larissa Waters and Rob Pyne arguing it demonstrated the need to change Queensland's abortion laws.[27] The girl's treating obstetrician David Macfarlane told a Queensland parliamentary inquiry into abortion law that the case set a precedent that young girls lacked capacity to give informed consent, injecting court involvement into situations that had earlier involved just the girl and medical staff.[28] The case led Labor-turned-independent politician Pyne to propose laws decriminalising abortion to the Queensland Parliament.[28]

On 10 May 2016 Rob Pyne introduced the Abortion Law Reform (Woman's Right to Choose) Amendment Bill 2016[29] to remove abortion from the Criminal Code.[30][31] The matter was referred to the Health, Communities, Disability Services and Domestic and Family Violence Prevention Committee, which also considered the termination of pregnancies in Queensland more broadly.[30] In August 2016 the Committee released its report,[32] recommending that the bill not be passed. The bill left several policy issues unregulated, including gestational limits, the rights of conscientious objectors and "safe access zones" near abortion providers.[8]

To address the issues on which the first bill was silent, on 27 August 2016 Pyne introduced the Health (Abortion Law Reform) Amendment Bill 2016.[33][34] This bill would amend the Health Act to require the approval of two doctors to terminate a pregnancy of 24 weeks or more, allow conscientious objection unless a woman's life was at risk and block abortion opponents from protesting within 50 metres of abortion clinics.[35] On 17 February 2017, the Committee issued its report with a split recommendation.[36] Liberal National Party members of the Committee raised concerns that if the second bill passed while the first failed, it would create legal confusion by subjecting abortion to conflicting criminal and health laws.[37]

On 28 February 2017 Pyne withdrew both bills after the Liberal National Party of Queensland signalled that none of its members would vote for the proposed laws.[38] The Labor Government promised to refer the matter of abortion to the Queensland Law Reform Commission for its recommendations and to introduce new laws in its next term of government if elected.[38]

2018 legalisation[edit]

A pro-life activist in Brisbane, 2018

Following the withdrawal of Pyne's bills, on 19 June 2017 Attorney-General Yvette D'Ath referred Queensland's pregnancy termination laws to the Queensland Law Reform Commission to review and recommend changes.[39][40] On 21 December 2017, the Commission released a consultation paper[41] and called for submissions from the public.[42] The Commission produced its report in June 2018.[43] On 22 August 2018 the Termination of Pregnancy Bill[44] was introduced to Parliament and referred to the Health, Communities, Disability Services and Domestic and Family Violence Prevention Committee for consideration.[45] The bill's Explanatory Notes outlined the proposed changes and noted they were informed by the Commission's report.[46] On 5 October 2018 the Committee's report was tabled, recommending that the law be passed and that all politicians be granted a conscience vote.[47][48]

The Queensland Parliament set aside three sitting days commencing 16 October 2018 to debate the proposed law.[49] Both the Labor Party and Liberal National Party allowed their members a conscience vote on the issue.[50] Politicians spoke emotionally and passionately both for and against the bill.[51][52][53]

The conscience vote split largely along party lines, with almost all members of the governing Labor Party voting in favour except Jo-Ann Miller who voted against and Linus Power who abstained. By contrast, almost all members of the opposition Liberal National Party of Queensland opposed the law apart from Jann Stuckey, Steve Minnikin and former party leader Tim Nicholls who voted in favour.[54] Liberal National party president Gary Spence had previously warned members of the party that their preselection would be at risk if they supported the law.[55] On the cross-bench, Independent Sandy Bolton and Greens MP Michael Berkman supported the law while the Katter's Australian Party and Pauline Hanson's One Nation MPs opposed it.[56] Political analysts noted the increased female representation in Parliament and in leadership roles across both major parties changed the debate compared to earlier discussions of abortion in the state.[57][58] There was a notable gender divide, a majority of those voting in favour were women, while most of those opposed were men (though two of the three LNP members who voted in favour were male).[59]

The legislation was granted royal assent on 25 October and went into effect on 3 December 2018.[60][61][1]

Details of 2018 Legislative Assembly vote to decriminalise abortion
Termination of Pregnancy Bill 2018 – Third Reading[62][56]
Party Votes for Votes against Abstained
Labor (48)
45
1
1
Liberal National (39)
3
36
 –
Katter's Australian (3) –
3
 –
Greens (1)
1
 – –
One Nation (Australia) (1) –
1
 –
Independent (1)
1
 – –
Total 50 41 1

Termination of Pregnancy Act 2018[edit]

A pro-choice activist in Brisbane, 2018

The Termination of Pregnancy Act outlines the legal framework governing abortions in Queensland.

Changes to Criminal Code[edit]

The Act repeals sections 224, 225 and 226 of the Criminal Code, removing the old criminal penalties for those performing, attempting or assisting in an abortion.[46] These are replaced with criminal penalties for an unqualified person who performs an abortion, who faces up to seven years imprisonment.[46] The Act makes it clear that a woman aborting her own pregnancy does not face any criminal liability.[46]

Gestational limit[edit]

Under the Act, a registered medical practitioner may perform an abortion on request in the first 22 weeks of pregnancy. A more advanced pregnancy may be terminated only after a second registered medical practitioner has been consulted and agrees that the abortion should be performed having regard to all medical circumstances; the woman's current and future physical, mental and social circumstances; and any relevant professional abortion standards and guidelines.[46] There is an exception allowing a post-22 week pregnancy to be aborted if the woman's life is at risk, or in the case of a multiple pregnancy, another unborn child's life.[46] A health practitioner who fails to comply with the requirements may face professional disciplinary action from the relevant professional regulator rather than criminal proceedings.[46]

Conscientious objectors[edit]

The Act does not require a medical practitioner to perform an abortion where this conflicts with their personal beliefs or values. Such a person is required to disclose their objection to the woman seeking an abortion and must transfer or refer her to an abortion provider who will perform it.[46] Conscientious objection does not limit the duties arising in an emergency.[46]

Safe access zones[edit]

The law makes it an offence to undertake "prohibited conduct" within 150 metres of an abortion provider, which includes any visible or audible communication about abortion regardless of whether it is seen or heard by people entering or leaving the premises.[46] People are also prohibited from making recordings of people entering or leaving an abortion provider's premises. The maximum penalty is 20 penalty units or one year imprisonment.[46]

Policy advocacy[edit]

A number of groups in the state actively lobby on both sides of the abortion debate, with protests held by supporters and opponents of decriminalisation.[63][64] Groups in favour include Children by Choice, Pro Choice Queensland and Fair Agenda.[65][66][67]

Groups opposed to abortion include Cherish Life Queensland and Project 139.[66] Project 139 demonstrated outside several abortion clinics in Brisbane.[66] The Catholic Church is actively opposed to reducing abortion restrictions,[68] raising among other concerns the risk of people engaging in sex-selective abortions.[69] Archbishop of Brisbane Mark Coleridge sent an email to Catholic school parents opposing the Termination of Pregnancy Act.[70]

Polling[edit]

A YouGov/Galaxy poll in August 2018, found that 60% of Queenslanders oppose abortions past 13 weeks.[71][72][73]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b "Termination of pregnancy legislation". Queensland Health. Queensland Government. 23 October 2018. Retrieved 24 October 2018.
  2. ^ Caldwell, Felicity (17 October 2018). "Abortion will no longer be a crime in Queensland after historic vote". Brisbane Times. Fairfax Media. Retrieved 22 October 2018.
  3. ^ Smee, Ben (17 October 2018). "Queensland parliament votes to legalise abortion". The Guardian. Retrieved 22 October 2018.
  4. ^ "Abortion access in Australia: How it works state by state". triple j. 20 February 2017. Retrieved 22 October 2018.
  5. ^ Smee, Ben (13 October 2018). "'You were shamed, punished': Queensland changes its mind on abortion". The Guardian. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  6. ^ Dumas, Daisy (2 November 2016). "Abortion access in Queensland is about to get even harder". The Sydney Morning Herald. Fairfax Media. Retrieved 1 November 2018.
  7. ^ "Australian abortion statistics - Children by Choice". Children by Choice. Children by Choice Association Incorporated. 19 September 2017. Retrieved 1 November 2018.
  8. ^ a b Dumas, Daisy (30 August 2016). "Queensland abortion law bill rejected, but reform is still an 'open question'". The Sydney Morning Herald. Fairfax Media. Retrieved 1 November 2018.
  9. ^ a b Douglas, Black & de Costa 2013, p. 562.
  10. ^ a b c d e Betts 2009, p. 26.
  11. ^ a b c d Smee, Ben (16 October 2018). "'They shot a rifle over my fence': the bitter fight for abortion rights in Queensland". The Guardian. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  12. ^ Holmes, Beryl (1982). "Struggle For Choice" (PDF). Children By Choice. Retrieved 1 January 2024.
  13. ^ Horn, Allyson (16 October 2018). "Police raids and arrests: Laws that let Sir Joh target abortion clinics could be scrapped". ABC News. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  14. ^ Douglas, Black & de Costa 2013, p. 563.
  15. ^ Douglas, Black & de Costa 2013, p. 564.
  16. ^ [1995] 2 Qd R 326
  17. ^ Cica, Natasha (31 August 1998). "Abortion Law in Australia". Research Papers 1998–99. Australian Parliamentary Library. Retrieved 23 October 2018.
  18. ^ a b Andersen, Brigid (2 September 2009). "Abortion laws 'still won't protect doctors'". ABC News. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 1 November 2018.
  19. ^ a b "Abortion couple not guilty". The Sydney Morning Herald. Fairfax Media. 14 October 2010. Retrieved 1 November 2018.
  20. ^ Nancarrow, Kirsty; Howells, Melinda (14 October 2010). "Couple not guilty in abortion trial". ABC News. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 1 November 2018.
  21. ^ Andersen, Brigid (25 August 2009). "Bligh not taking abortion laws to Parliament". ABC News. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 1 November 2018.
  22. ^ a b "Abortion amendments to criminal code pass parliament". Brisbane Times. Fairfax Media. 3 September 2009. Retrieved 1 November 2018.
  23. ^ Wallace, Jim (26 August 2009). "Bligh is right to resist abortion radicals". Crikey. Retrieved 1 November 2018.
  24. ^ Criminal Code (Medical Amendment) Bill 2009.
  25. ^ Central Queensland Hospital and Health Service v Q [2016] QSC 89 (26 April 2016), Supreme Court (Qld, Australia)
  26. ^ Higgins, Isabella (27 April 2016). "12yo girl granted permission for abortion". ABC News. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 13 November 2018.
  27. ^ a b Robertson, Joshua (27 April 2016). "Girl, aged 12, forced to wait weeks for Australian court to approve abortion". The Guardian. Retrieved 13 November 2018.
  28. ^ a b Robertson, Joshua (15 June 2016). "Queensland doctor in abortion case says more teenagers face 'appalling' choice". The Guardian. Retrieved 13 November 2018.
  29. ^ Abortion Law Reform (Woman's Right to Choose) Amendment Bill 2016.
  30. ^ a b Health, Communities, Disability Services and Domestic and Family Violence Prevention Committee. "Abortion Law Reform (Woman's Right to Choose) Amendment Bill 2016 and Inquiry into laws governing termination of pregnancy in Queensland". Work of Committees. Parliament of Queensland. Retrieved 13 November 2018.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  31. ^ Paull, Nathan (10 May 2016). "Qld LNP allows abortion conscience vote". Yahoo7 News. Australian Associated Press. Retrieved 13 November 2018.
  32. ^ Health, Communities, Disability Services and Domestic and Family Violence Prevention Committee (August 2016). "Report No. 24, 55th Parliament: Abortion Law Reform (Woman's Right to Choose) Amendment Bill 2016 and Inquiry into laws governing termination of pregnancy in Queensland" (PDF). Parliamentary Committees. Parliament of Queensland. Retrieved 13 November 2018.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  33. ^ Health (Abortion Law Reform) Amendment Bill 2016.
  34. ^ Health, Communities, Disability Services and Domestic and Family Violence Prevention Committee. "Health (Abortion Law Reform) Amendment Bill 2016". Work of Committees. Parliament of Queensland. Retrieved 13 November 2018.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  35. ^ Wong, Rachael (23 August 2016). "Women Deserve Better than the Proposed Abortion Law Reform". ABC Religion & Ethics. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 13 November 2018.
  36. ^ Health, Communities, Disability Services and Domestic and Family Violence Prevention Committee (February 2017). "Report No. 33, 55th Parliament: Health (Abortion Law Reform) Amendment Bill 2016" (PDF). Parliamentary Committees. Parliament of Queensland. Retrieved 13 November 2018.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  37. ^ Caldwell, Felicity (17 February 2017). "Qld abortion bill: Pyne hails victory over committee split". Brisbane Times. Fairfax Media. Retrieved 13 November 2018.
  38. ^ a b O'Brien, Chris (28 February 2017). "Queensland abortion decriminalisation bills withdrawn". ABC News. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 23 October 2018.
  39. ^ D'Ath, Yvette (13 June 2017). "Terms of Reference: Queensland's laws relating to the termination of pregnancy" (PDF). QLRC. Queensland Law Reform Commission. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  40. ^ "Queensland Law Reform Commission report on termination of pregnancy laws – tabled in Parliament on 16 July 2018". Newsroom. Queensland Law Reform Commission. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  41. ^ "Review of termination of pregnancy laws: Consultation Paper" (PDF). QLRC. Queensland Law Reform Commission. December 2017. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  42. ^ "Queensland Law Reform Commission releases a consultation paper calling for submissions on Queensland's laws relating to the termination of pregnancy – 21 December 2017". Newsroom. Queensland Law Reform Commission. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  43. ^ "Report No 76: Review of termination of pregnancy laws" (PDF). QLRC. Queensland Law Reform Commission. June 2018. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  44. ^ Termination of Pregnancy Bill.
  45. ^ Layt, Stuart (22 August 2018). "Abortion reform laws introduced in Queensland". The New Daily. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  46. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k "Termination of Pregnancy Bill 2018 Explanatory Notes" (PDF). Parliament of Queensland. State of Queensland. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  47. ^ Health, Communities, Disability Services and Domestic and Family Violence Prevention Committee (October 2018). "Report No. 11 - 56th Parliament - Termination of Pregnancy Bill 2018" (PDF). Queensland Parliament. State of Queensland. Retrieved 30 October 2018.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  48. ^ Caldwell, Felicity (5 October 2018). "Committee recommends conscience vote on abortion". Brisbane Times. Fairfax Media. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  49. ^ "Pro-life groupsQLD abortion debate to take three days". News.com.au. News Corp Australia. 16 October 2018. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  50. ^ Smee, Ben (9 October 2018). "Queensland abortion legalisation to be put to conscience vote". The Guardian. Retrieved 22 October 2018.
  51. ^ Horn, Allyson (17 October 2018). "Politicians break down during emotional Queensland abortion bill debate". ABC News. Retrieved 22 October 2018.
  52. ^ Caldwell, Felicity (9 October 2018). "LNP to allow its MPs a conscience vote on Queensland abortion reform". Brisbane Times. Fairfax Media. Retrieved 22 October 2018.
  53. ^ Caldwell, Felicity (18 October 2018). "Queensland abortion reform: The most memorable quotes of the debate". Brisbane Times. Fairfax Media. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  54. ^ Caldwell, Felicity (18 October 2018). "Pro-life group vows to target MPs who supported abortion". Brisbane Times. Fairfax Media. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  55. ^ Layt, Stuart (11 September 2018). "Qld LNP MPs pressured over abortion laws". Yahoo7 News. Australian Associated Press. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  56. ^ a b Horn, Allyson (17 October 2018). "Abortion no longer a crime in Queensland after historic vote". ABC News. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 22 October 2018.
  57. ^ Rojas, Rick (15 October 2018). "Abortion Debate in Australia Has a New Element: Women in Power". New York Times. Retrieved 13 November 2018.
  58. ^ Rojas, Rick (17 October 2018). "Queensland Becomes Latest Australian State to Decriminalize Abortion". New York Times. Retrieved 13 November 2018.
  59. ^ Sullivan, Rebecca (18 October 2018). "Queensland abortion laws passed: List of MPs shows it was mostly men who voted to keep abortion illegal". News.com.au. News Corp Australia. Retrieved 28 November 2018.
  60. ^ "Termination of Pregnancy Act 2018". legislation.qld.gov.au.
  61. ^ "Proclamation made under the Termination of Pregnancy Act 2018". legislation.qld.gov.au.
  62. ^ "Termination of Pregnancy Bill 2018 – Third Reading" (PDF). Record of Proceedings (Hansard). Queensland: Legislative Assembly. 17 October 2018. p. 2958.
  63. ^ Caldwell, Felicity (1 September 2018). "Brisbane rally against abortion decriminalisation laws attracts thousands". Brisbane Times. Fairfax Media. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  64. ^ Gleeson, Hayley (19 November 2016). "The fight for abortion law reform: Have feminists dropped the ball?". ABC News. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  65. ^ Mitchell-Whittington, Amy (26 October 2015). "Queensland abortion laws to stay the same: D'Ath". Brisbane Times. Fairfax Media. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  66. ^ a b c Smee, Ben (18 June 2018). "Evangelical Christians step up abortion clinic protests in Queensland". The Guardian. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  67. ^ Brown, Alison (14 October 2018). "Doctors, nurses and pollies march in support of abortion reform". Brisbane Times. Fairfax Media. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  68. ^ "Abortion and law reform". Archdiocese of Brisbane - Catholic Church in South East Queensland. Archdiocese of Brisbane. 26 August 2009. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  69. ^ Sheehan, Catherine (12 September 2018). "Qld abortion law will allow targeting girls". The Catholic Weekly. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  70. ^ Brown, Alison (1 September 2018). "Brisbane mother slams Catholic Church for 'linking abortion with child abuse'". Brisbane Times. Fairfax Media. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
  71. ^ Queenslanders Attitudes on Abortion. Cherish Life. Retrieved on 20 October 2023.
  72. ^ Toby Crockford. (19 August 2018). Queensland MPs who support abortion reform face voter backlash: poll. Brisbane Times. Retrieved on 20 October 2023.
  73. ^ Des Houghton. (18 August 2018). Poll finds majority of Queensland voters oppose key plank of Labor abortion reform. The West Australian. Retrieved on 20 October 2023.

Bibliography[edit]

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Abortion_in_Queensland&oldid=1212270657"