Association | Year | Category | Nominated Work | Result |
20/20 Awards | 2016 | Best Actor | Living in Oblivion | Nominated |
American Film Institute Awards | 2002 | Feature Actor of the Year – Male — Movies | Ghost World | Nominated |
American Comedy Awards | 1997 | Funniest Actor in a Motion Picture | Fargo | Nominated |
Awards Circuit Community Awards | 1996 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role | Won |
Best Cast Ensemble | Won |
Behind the Voice Actors Awards | 2013 | Best Vocal Ensemble in a Feature Film | Hotel Transylvania | Nominated |
2014 | Best Vocal Ensemble in a Feature Film | Monster's University | Nominated |
2015 | Best Male Vocal Performance in a TV Special/Direct-to-Video Title or Short | Khumba | Nominated |
Boston Society of Film Critics Awards | 2001 | Best Supporting Actor | Ghost World | Nominated |
British Independent Film Awards | 2017 | Best Supporting Actor | The Death of Stalin | Nominated |
Chicago Film Critics Association Awards | 1997 | Best Supporting Actor | Fargo | Nominated |
2002 | Best Supporting Actor | Ghost World | Won |
Chlotrudis Awards | 1997 | Best Director | Trees Lounge | Nominated |
2002 | Best Supporting Actor | Ghost World | Won |
Crime Thriller Awards | 2011 | Best Leading Actor | Boardwalk Empire | Nominated |
2012 | Best Leading Actor | Nominated |
Critics Choice Television Awards | 2011 | Best Actor in a Drama Series | Nominated |
Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association Awards | 2002 | Best Supporting Actor | Ghost World | Nominated |
Directors Guild of America | 1999 | Outstanding Directorial Achievement in Dramatic Series' – Night | Homicide: Life on the Street | Nominated |
2002 | Outstanding Directorial Achievement in Dramatic Series' – Night | The Sopranos | Nominated |
DVD Exclusive Awards | 2003 | Best Supporting Actor | Double Whammy | Nominated |
Fantasporto Awards | 2008 | Best Screenplay | Interview | Won |
Film Club's The Lost Weekend | 2018 | Best Supporting Actor | The Death of Stalin | Won |
Florida Film Festival | 1998 | Special Achievement Award | — | Won |
German Film Awards | 2009 | Best Supporting Actor | John Rabe | Nominated |
Ghent International Film Festival | 2005 | Grand Prix | Lonesome Jim | Nominated |
Gijon International Film Festival | 2007 | Best Feature | Interview | Nominated |
Gold Derby Awards | 2004 | Drama Supporting Actor | The Sopranos | Nominated |
2011 | Drama Lead Actor | Boardwalk Empire | Nominated |
Golden Schmoes Awards | 2001 | Best Supporting Actor of the Year | Ghost World | Nominated |
Gotham Awards | 2003 | Tribute Award | — | Won |
Kansas City Film Critics Circle Awards | 2001 | Best Supporting Actor | Ghost World | Won |
Las Vegas Film Critics Society Awards | 2002 | Best Supporting Actor | Won |
Method Fest | 2010 | Feature Film | Handsome Harry | Nominated |
Monte-Carlo TV Festival | 2012 | Outstanding Actor in a Drama Series | Boardwalk Empire | Nominated |
MTV Movie + TV Awards | 1997 | Best On-Screen Duo (shared with Peter Stormare) | Fargo | Nominated |
National Society of Film Critics Awards | 2002 | Best Supporting Actor | Ghost World | Won |
New York Film Critics Circle Awards | 2001 | Best Supporting Actor | Won |
New York Film Critics Online | Best Supporting Actor | Won |
News & Documentary Emmy Awards | 2015 | Outstanding Business and Economic Reporting – Long Form | Independent Lens | Won |
Online Film & Television Association Awards | 2002 | Best Supporting Actor | Ghost World | Nominated |
2004 | Best Supporting Actor in a Drama Series | The Sopranos | Nominated |
2008 | Best Guest Actor in a Drama Series | ER | Nominated |
2011 | Best Actor in a Drama Series | Boardwalk Empire | Won |
Best Ensemble in a Drama Series | Won |
2012 | Best Actor in a Drama Series | Nominated |
Best Ensemble in a Drama Series | Nominated |
2013 | Best Actor in a Drama Series | Nominated |
Best Ensemble in a Drama Series | Nominated |
2014 | Best Guest Actor in a Comedy Series | Portlandia | Nominated |
Online Film Critics Society Awards | 2002 | Best Supporting Actor | Ghost World | Won |
Philadelphia Film Festival | 2005 | American Independents Award | — | Won |
Phoenix Film Critics Society Awards | 2002 | Best Supporting Actor | Ghost World | Nominated |
San Diego Film Critics Society Awards | 2001 | Special Award | Ghost World Monsters, Inc. Double Whammy Domestic Disturbance Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within | Won |
San Jordi Awards | 1997 | Best Foreign Actor | Fargo Living in Oblivion | Won |
Satellite Awards | Best Supporting Actor in a Motion Picture — Drama | Fargo | Nominated |
2002 | Best Supporting Actor in a Motion Picture — Comedy or Musical | Ghost World | Nominated |
2011 | Best Actor in a Series — Drama | Boardwalk Empire | Nominated |
Saturn Awards | 1998 | Best Supporting Actor | Con Air | Nominated |
Southeastern Film Critics Association Awards | 2001 | Best Supporting Actor | Ghost World | Nominated |
Stockholm Film Festival | 2000 | Bronze Horse Award | Animal Factory | Nominated |
Sundance Film Festival | 2005 | Dramatic | Lonesome Jim | Nominated |
Television Critics Association Awards | 2011 | Individual Achievement in Drama | Boardwalk Empire | Nominated |
Toronto Film Critics Association Awards | 2001 | Best Supporting Performance – Male | Ghost World | Nominated |
Vancouver Film Critics Circle Awards | 2002 | Best Actor | Won |
Village Voice Film Poll Awards | 2001 | Best Supporting Performance | Won |